Contact Us
Semrush and Me: A Charlotte SEO Agency’s Love-Hate Relationship
As a Charlotte SEO agency that has spent years navigating every primary tool in the industry, we’ve developed a complex relationship with Semrush. We’ve been in a long-term relationship with this platform—one that’s equal parts admiration and exasperation. Like any solid partnership, there are moments of brilliance, followed by the occasional raised eyebrow. We rely on advanced tools to deliver results that clients can measure, and Semrush has undoubtedly been part of that toolkit. But as with all good things in tech, there’s always room for improvement—and we’re not shy about saying it.
We’re not here to cancel Semrush. Far from it. Our team uses it daily, especially when we’re auditing websites, tracking rankings, or exploring opportunities for local businesses. But just like you can love a car and still hate the cup holders, we’ve developed a few thoughts—some fond, some frustrated—about what it’s like to use Semrush in the day-to-day trenches of search engine optimization.
Semrush’s Charm Offensive: What Keeps Me Coming Back
Let’s be honest—despite its quirks, Semrush has a lot going for it. We’ve used nearly every primary tool in the SEO universe, and few offer the range and depth that Semrush delivers. From the Keyword Magic Tool to Position Tracking and Domain Overview, there’s rarely a campaign where we don’t turn to it for insights. I recall conducting a technical audit for one of our e-commerce clients in Charlotte, and within two months of implementing the findings, their organic traffic increased by 28%. Those are the kinds of results that keep us coming back.
And we’re not alone. Global brands like Tesla, Apple, and even Google have leveraged Semrush for insights, which is both impressive and slightly ironic. According to industry reports, Semrush has over 100,000 active paid users—meaning it’s not just a favorite for small teams but a heavyweight in the global SEO scene. For a Charlotte SEO agency navigating high expectations and competitive markets, it helps to have a tool with that kind of credibility—even if it occasionally acts like it’s billing by stealth mode.
Pricing Trickery: The Subscription Dance Begins
Here’s where the honeymoon phase with Semrush starts to unravel. When I decided to explore their Local SEO package to support our growing roster of small businesses in the area, everything looked promising—location tracking, reputation management, citation monitoring. But almost immediately after signing up, I realized I’d stepped into a subscription maze with no exit signs. There was no simple way to cancel or downgrade the plan. To even consider unsubscribing, I had to go through the full support gauntlet—multiple reps, repeated explanations, and a lot of “we’ll get back to you shortly” emails.
This kind of runaround might be expected from your internet provider, but not from a sophisticated SaaS tool. As a Charlotte SEO agency that emphasizes transparency with our clients, I found this especially frustrating. It’s not just about the money—it’s the principle. A platform built for digital professionals should offer a seamless way to manage subscriptions without the drama. Instead, Semrush seems to have taken a page from the “hold your customers hostage” playbook, and no one enjoys that chapter.
Local Pack Blues: Extra Seats, Extra Fees, and No Easy Way Back
As our team at Above Bits grew, it made perfect sense to add another user to our Semrush account. A new SEO expert has joined the team, and assigning them a seat felt like a straightforward and logical step. The real surprise came later, when that team member transitioned to another project, and we tried to remove their user seat. Spoiler alert: our bill didn’t budge. We were still being charged for two users, and reverting to a single seat wasn’t something we could do ourselves. Returning to a previous pricing tier requires another trip through the customer support forest.
To put it plainly, it’s baffling. Imagine Netflix continuing to charge you for two screens after you cancel one of them. Or Zoom billing you as if you’re hosting a 300-person webinar when it’s just you and your dog. As a Charlotte SEO agency managing budgets for local businesses and non-profits alike, every dollar counts—and platform quirks like these feel less like oversight and more like design. Tools meant to streamline our work shouldn’t make us feel like we’re solving a riddle to downgrade a plan.
Transparency Is Crucial—Take a Cue from Global Players
If there’s one lesson modern software companies should’ve learned by now, it’s this: transparency builds trust. Giants like Amazon Prime and Slack, despite their occasional stumbles, have figured out how to communicate what you’re being charged for clearly and when. When pricing changes or features are updated, users receive fair warning and easy access to their billing details. That kind of clarity is gold, especially in industries like SEO, where professionals rely on data-driven platforms to make informed, intelligent decisions quickly.
It’s one reason we’ve made transparency a non-negotiable policy at Above Bits. As a Charlotte SEO agency, we work with businesses that don’t have time—or money—to waste on surprises. And if they expect openness from us, we should be able to predict the same from the tools we trust. Semrush, despite its brilliance, still hides too much behind vague menus and difficult-to-reach support options. A clear, upfront billing structure wouldn’t just reduce frustration—it would raise their reputation across the board.
Semrush’s Curious Backlink Analytics: A Case of Déjà Vu
One of the main reasons we rely on tools like Semrush is to monitor backlinks—those crucial signals that still carry massive SEO weight. But imagine our surprise when the backlink report for our website, abovebits.com, showed no meaningful updates… for over six months. Initially, we suspected it might be a glitch or a caching issue. Nope. After contacting Semrush support, they confirmed it: the backlink database is updated roughly once a year. In SEO terms, that’s the equivalent of sending a postcard in a world run by push notifications.
That kind of delay just doesn’t cut it anymore. We live in a world where algorithms evolve daily and competitors shift strategies hourly. Tools like Ahrefs update their backlink data every 15 minutes. Moz follows a similar cadence. As a Charlotte SEO agency, we rely on up-to-date backlink intelligence to inform content strategy, evaluate link-building efforts, and refine our techniques. Outdated data means we’re flying blind—and that’s not the kind of insight any SEO professional should be paying premium prices for.
Global Backlink Importance: Why Semrush Should Fix This Quickly
Backlinks are still one of the strongest signals Google uses to determine where a website should appear in search results. A 2023 study by Search Engine Journal listed backlinks as the second most influential ranking factor, second only to content quality. That means having a stale backlink index isn’t a minor inconvenience; it can skew decisions, mislead clients, and negatively impact real-world performance. SEO professionals need timely data to execute winning strategies, and the industry is aware of this.
For a Charlotte SEO agency like ours, staying ahead of the curve means adapting fast and basing decisions on real-time information. Whether we’re tracking competitors or evaluating the impact of a new campaign, we can’t afford to rely on last year’s link profile. It’s like trying to navigate rush hour with the previous month’s traffic map. If Semrush wants to maintain its position as a global SEO powerhouse, it needs to prioritize backlink freshness as a core aspect, not a secondary consideration.
A Quick Fix: Transparency, Honesty, or More Frequent Updates?
Solving Semrush’s backlink update issue isn’t rocket science—it’s a matter of priorities. At the very least, they could be upfront about how often the data is refreshed. It might not be the ideal solution, but it’s honest. Users can make informed choices when they know what they’re working with. Hiding the update schedule behind vague language only adds to the frustration and leaves SEO teams guessing, which is never a good look for a premium analytics platform.
Of course, the better solution is to update more frequently. Weekly or monthly would be a giant leap forward and show that Semrush is willing to invest in what its users need. As a Charlotte SEO agency that works with businesses that expect fast, informed decisions, we rely on live, accurate metrics. We’ve seen firsthand how stale data can undermine a campaign’s momentum. A simple shift toward more transparency—or more frequent updates—could turn a loyal-but-frustrated user base into true advocates.
The Subscription Saga Continues: Semrush Pricing Tricks Revisited
At this point, it’s clear that Semrush’s subscription practices are more than just minor annoyances—they’re potential dealbreakers. When you have to jump through hoops to cancel a feature or adjust your billing, it’s not a minor UX flaw. It’s a sign that the platform might be more focused on retention by friction than on satisfaction. And that’s a dangerous game in a competitive market filled with alternatives that are just a click away.
We’ve spoken with colleagues, clients, and other professionals in the SEO space, and the complaints are surprisingly consistent. When tools make it difficult to leave, people eventually stop signing up. As a Charlotte SEO agency that’s handled everything from local startups to statewide campaigns, we’ve learned that clarity keeps people coming back. If Semrush wants to evolve from being “the best option right now” to “the obvious choice long-term,” it needs to fix these billing tricks before users decide the trust deficit isn’t worth the analytics payoff.
How One Charlotte SEO Agency Navigates Semrush’s Local SEO Maze
Semrush’s Local Listing Management Tool sounds fantastic on paper. Manage citations, track local visibility, monitor reviews—all critical components for any business trying to dominate local search. But when we signed up to expand our regional strategy, things quickly got murky. Essential functions, such as updating listings across directories, triggered unexpected charges that were not disclosed during the initial sign-up process. It felt like ordering a fully loaded pizza and finding out halfway through that toppings cost extra, one by one.
This level of ambiguity creates tension where clarity is needed. Local SEO is already complex; the tools built to support it shouldn’t add more confusion. As a Charlotte SEO agency working with small and midsize businesses that rely heavily on localized results, we can’t afford “surprise” features behind invisible paywalls. When managing multiple listings, clients depend on us to keep things simple, and we rely on our tools to do the same. Unfortunately, Semrush’s local solution still feels like a work in progress, albeit one presented as a premium product.
Why Backlink Delays Frustrate Every Charlotte SEO Agency
If it feels like we’re harping on backlinks, it’s because they matter—a lot. In competitive SEO environments, even minor changes to your backlink profile can lead to significant shifts in search visibility. That’s why it’s so disappointing that Semrush, with all its resources, still lags in this area. Tools like Ahrefs have made backlink freshness a core feature, and users have taken notice. For professionals paying premium rates, getting outdated data wrapped in a slick UI doesn’t feel like a value—it feels like a compromise.
From our side, as a Charlotte SEO agency managing live campaigns and tracking off-page SEO for dozens of clients, waiting a year for updated link data doesn’t align with how fast the digital world moves. Clients expect monthly reports that reflect real progress, not approximations based on old snapshots. If Semrush doesn’t catch up here, it risks becoming a tool for retrospective audits instead of a proactive strategy, which is not what the modern SEO world needs.
What Every Charlotte SEO Agency Wants from a Subscription Dashboard
After wrestling with subscription upgrades, downgrades, surprise fees, and support tickets, one obvious solution kept coming to mind: a clean, intuitive subscription dashboard. Imagine logging in and instantly seeing all your active features, user seats, pricing tiers, and cancellation options—no mystery, no middlemen. It’s a basic expectation in 2025. And yet, with Semrush, managing your subscription feels more like filing your taxes than using a modern SaaS tool.
Plenty of other platforms have already figured this out. HubSpot, Adobe, Salesforce—they’ve all improved user retention by making it easy to manage accounts directly. A Charlotte SEO agency like ours doesn’t have time to chase down billing reps or escalate routine requests. We need to be spending that time analyzing SERPs, improving rankings, and helping our clients grow. A user-friendly dashboard wouldn’t just be a UX improvement—it would signal that Semrush values its users’ time.
Lessons from Big Tech Every Charlotte SEO Agency Pays Attention To
The most prominent players in the SaaS world didn’t earn their reputations by trapping users in billing cycles—they built trust through clarity. Adobe, for example, faced severe backlash in 2020 for convoluted subscription terms. But instead of doubling down, they pivoted: simplified pricing, more precise cancellation steps, and a more user-friendly experience. The result? Happier users, better reviews, and increased retention. It turns out people aren’t afraid to pay more—if they understand precisely what they’re getting.
It’s a lesson Semrush would do well to absorb. If they rolled out transparent billing breakdowns and eliminated the fine print, they’d likely see a bump in loyalty overnight. As a Charlotte SEO agency, we’ve worked with clients across various industries—healthcare, retail, and education—and have seen firsthand how much goodwill is built simply by being upfront. Tools that follow that same principle instantly become more than platforms—they become partners.
A Global Perspective: Consumers Expect Honesty (And Will Reward It!)
Across the globe, one theme keeps emerging in SaaS customer behavior: honesty breeds loyalty. A Nielsen study revealed that 73% of consumers are willing to stick with a brand, even at a higher price, if that brand is transparent about costs. In an era where people manage a dozen subscriptions across tools, apps, and platforms, clarity isn’t just appreciated—it’s expected. Hiding fees or burying cancellation steps isn’t clever anymore—it’s outdated.
We’ve built our reputation as a Charlotte SEO agency by following this exact principle. Whether we’re managing long-term SEO campaigns or launching a new digital storefront, we communicate what to expect upfront. It builds trust, and trust builds retention. Suppose Semrush adopted that same philosophy across their platform, from local SEO tools to backlink data. In that case, they’d not only reduce user churn but also earn many more vocal advocates in every corner of the industry.
The Path Ahead: My Friendly Recommendations to Semrush
After years of using Semrush daily, I can say with confidence that most of its frustrations aren’t technical—they’re policy-driven. The tools themselves are incredibly robust. The dashboards? Sleek. The analytics? Often game-changing. However, user trust erodes when account management feels like an obstacle course and backlink data moves at a glacial pace. The good news? None of these problems is insurmountable.
If Semrush wants to become the platform SEO pros swear by—not just tolerate—there are a few easy wins on the table. As a Charlotte SEO agency with deep ties to our clients and their expectations, here’s what we believe could make a big difference:
- Build a self-service subscription dashboard that enables easy addition or removal of features without requiring a support ticket.
- Update backlink data more frequently, or at the very least, clearly disclose the exact refresh schedule.
- Clean up Local SEO pricing by showing all potential fees upfront, rather than hiding them behind “add-ons.”
- Study the SaaS giants—HubSpot, Adobe, and others—who’ve already mastered the art of billing transparency.
These aren’t revolutionary ideas—they’re basic standards for any platform that wants to lead the SEO space instead of occupy it.
Final Thoughts from Above Bits: Clarity, Trust, and Transparency
In our experience, the best digital tools don’t just offer data—they offer trust. At Above Bits, whether we’re diving deep into technical audits or building SEO strategies from scratch, we’ve learned that clarity is the secret ingredient. Our clients appreciate when we’re transparent about timelines, costs, and expectations—and that’s precisely what we look for in the platforms we use every day. The moment a tool adds friction, hides fees, or withholds updates, it stops being a partner and starts becoming a liability.
As a Charlotte SEO agency serving businesses that can’t afford guesswork, we believe Semrush still has everything it needs to be exceptional. The technology is already there. What’s missing is the human-first approach—the willingness to put the user’s experience and trust above lock-in tactics. If Semrush embodies transparency in the same way we’ve built it into our foundation, it won’t just be a great SEO tool; it will be a truly exceptional one. It’ll be the one we recommend without hesitation.
If you’re curious how we apply these insights in real-world campaigns—or want a more straightforward approach to SEO—you can see what we’re working on over here.